"Thankfully, [it's] is hardly a credulous retelling of Stewart's story (...) Davidson allows the author to have his say and add new evidence that he's uncovered since the book's publication, but his team also does what Stewart's publisher, Harper Collins, apparently never did: fact-check his assertions." 

"A solid entry into the true-crime docu-series genre (...) The episodes are swift and engrossing while never overstaying their welcome. They are what they need to be and do a heck of a job succeeding where they wish to succeed." 

"[It] is intriguing enough to spend three-and-a-half hours on, but you may find yourself wondering why this story couldn’t have been told in half the time. 

"It actually eventually serves as an interesting companion to one of the best films of the ‘00s, David Fincher’s 'Zodiac'." 

"Its four-episode counts makes it an easy investment, one whose ultimate turn is bizarre but feels like a perfect fit for this strange case’s natural twists"